PRIVACY POLICY. Ralph Miliband, “Marx and the State” (1965) 2 Socialist Register 278; Axel van den Berg, The Immanent Utopia: From Marxism on the State to the State of Marxism (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1988). It is clear that the terms “right” and “law” are used here not in their direct sense, but by analogy. A second major tributary of thinking about the state came from debates in Italian Marxism following the rise of fascism. As I will suggest, much of what is offered as Marxist theory of law satisfies one From this perspective Soviet law is seen exclusively as a legacy of class society imposed on the proletariat and which haunts it until the second phase of communism. It suffices to mention the work of Barnave – one of the architects of the great French Revolution – who in the same way sought explanations of political struggle and the political order in property relations. On this basis Marx defined the state and all its laws as mere instruments of class domination, which … The struggle for revolutionary legality is a struggle on two fronts: against legal formalism and the transfer to Soviet soil of bourgeois chicanery, and against those who do not understand the organizational significance of Soviet decrees as one of the methods of the uniform conduct of the policy of the dictatorship of the proletariat. This definition stresses three aspects of the matter. As Shlomo Avineri points out, despite its disorganised nature, Marx’s 1843 Critique of the Philosophy of Right (hereafter 1843 Critique) is his most systematic work on political theory.5 Marx’s engagement with German philosophy generally, and Hegel’s PoR specifically, was premised on his understanding that what Germany lacked in social and economic development it made up for in philoso… This definition also introduces confusion because it confuses law with economics. Neo-Marxism and the Origin of the Committee on States and Social Structures” (2019) 72 Political Research Quarterly 714. Jürgen Habermas, Legitimation Crisis, trans. Even Karl Marx gave a small tribute to this concept when he spoke of law as an ideological superstructure. It is not only important to “read” the norm, but also to know what class, what state, and what state apparatus is applying this norm. Despite this general proliferation of interest in Marxist critiques of pluralist and elitist theories of power, by the mid-1980s, the research framework entered a period of decline alongside the New Left.38Rafael Khachaturian, “Bringing What State Back In? Bourgeois property includes in a masked form the same relationship of domination and subordination which, in feudal property, appears chiefly as personal subordination. The theoretical mistake of exaggerating the importance of market relations can be the basis for right opportunist conclusions about always preserving the bourgeois forms of law corresponding to private exchange. Pashukanis theorized law as an expression of the contractual and transactional nature of capitalist society; consequently, the revolution in the relations of production would lead to the withering away of law and its replacement by administration following the completed transition to communist society. This professorial scholasticism has the attractive feature for the bourgeoisie that verbal and formalistic contrivances can hide the ugly reality of [their] exploiting society and exploiting law. Learn how your comment data is processed. Therefore, it is a flagrant error to equate law as an historical phenomenon – including various class systems – with the totality of those features of bourgeois law that derive from the exchange of commodities of equal value. Law and Marxism: the state and the constitution COM_CONTENT_ARTICLE_INFO Ben Gliniecki 15 February 2018 Last year, constitutional crises arose in Britain, the USA, Spain, Poland, and Brazil. Subsequent Marxist theorists of law have been led to one of two courses: either to cling to the transition from civil society to the state and in the process to abandon fundamentals of historical materialism, or to borrow from orthodox academic legal theory. Property relationships occupy the prominent place in the characterization of a specific legal order. While this post cannot resolve these challenges, my contention is that any inquiry into the “Marxist theory of the state” is inseparable from the history of Marxist debates about the state, as these debates were conducted on shifting political, strategic, and theoretical terrains over the course of the tradition’s development. Economic Relations and the Law. Rafael Khachaturian is Lecturer at the University of Pennsylvania, Associate Faculty at the Brooklyn Institute for Social Research, and on the editorial committee of Socialist Forum. This professorial rubbish is presented without the least attempt at factual proof In actuality it would be rather difficult to explain how this “unity of the legal idea and its equal appearance” gave birth to the laws of the Twelve Tablets of slave-owning Rome, the serf customs of the Middle Ages, the declarations of rights of capitalist democracies, and our Soviet Constitution. While Marxism strives to give a concrete historical meaning to law, the characteristic feature of bourgeois philosophers of law is, on the contrary, the conclusion that law in general is outside classes, outside any particular socio-economic formation. Marx’s analysis of the state thus spanned two related but nevertheless distinct standpoints: the  philosophical perspective of his earlier writing, where the state is a juridical fiction that masks the class interests openly expressed in civil society, and a historical-political perspective where it is a social relation that reproduces a specific balance of forces in society. But the basic qualitative difference between this superstructure and the political and legal superstructures of class society, consists in the absence of property inequality, exploitation, and organized class coercion. Cemal Burak Tansel (ed), States of Discipline: Authoritarian Neoliberalism and the Contested Reproduction of the Capitalist Order (London: Rowman & Littlefield, 2017); Ian Bruff and Cemal Burak Tansel (eds), Authoritarian Neoliberalism: Philosophies, Practices, Contestations (London: Taylor & Francis, 2019). Ideology as Law and Law as Ideology. However, the essential and basic – that which provides the guiding theme for the study of different legal institutions – is the difference between the position of the slave, the position of the serf and the position of the wage labourer. Discussions of the state in the Marxist tradition have generally been situated amidst specific disputes about the strategies that working-class movements and parties should adopt in the face of organized political power. The book argues that the main purpose of a Marxist theory of law is to expose the belief in the Rule of Law as being a subtle and pervasive ideology which serves to obscure the structures of class domination within the State. Consider the fact that there are … Alternative Marxist Approaches to Law. This consists of using formal logical conclusions in order to move from particular norms to more general concepts and back, proceeding from general positions to propose the solution of concrete legal cases or disputes. He believed that proletariat law practised in erstwhile Soviet Union needed alternative general concepts to reinforce Marxist theory of law. The objective of the Marxist theory of law is to examine the role played by law in increasing or preserving the prevailing inequality in society. Engels further developed this view in his Origin of the Family, Private Property, and the State, suggesting that the state had emerged from the gradual division of labour in settled civilizations to moderate the resulting class antagonisms. Soviet law, like any law, will cease to exist if it is not applied. The first, or in Stuchka’s words, the concrete form of law, is a legal relationship which corresponds to a production relationship and, with it, constitutes the base [or] reality. Thomas McCarthy (Boston: Beacon Press, 1975); Claus Offe, Contradictions of the Welfare State, ed. Stammler proposes that the concrete study of legal phenomena is entirely unable to provide anything in the understanding of the essence of law. Law (and the state) appears with the division of society into classes. The role of the jurist remained the logical interpretation of particular legal provisions, the establishment of an internal logical connection between them, combining them into larger systematic units in legal institutions, and finally in this way the creation of a system of law. The conscious will – towards the formulation and consolidation of production and other relationships – is the will of the ruling class which finds its expression in custom, in law, in the activity of the court and in administration. This statement is the influence of Marx's thorough transformation of law studies and a general perception among elites of judicial system. Later commentators have thus faced the challenge of recomposing his scattered writings on the topic spanning from the 1840s to the 1880s into a more coherent and systematic theory. Although this has been explained as the gap between the young and the mature Marx, there are also certain continuities.11Louis Althusser, For Marx (London: Verso, 1965). Such a distortion in the description of NEP led directly to an alliance with bourgeois reformists in the understanding of Soviet law. As such, it is radically different from bourgeois law despite the formal resemblance of individual statutes. Coercive power exists in every human society – both in the tribal structure and in the family, but there was no state.” And further, Lenin concludes: “The distinguishing feature of the state is the existence of a separate class of people in whose hands power is concentrated. Piers Beirne and Robert Sharlet (London: Academic Press, 1980). Kellen – one of the most recent Swedish theorists of the state – distinguishes five elements or phenomena of the state: territory, people, economy, society and, finally, the state as the formal legal subject of power. The other was the “capital logic” school, which sought to derive the form of the capitalist state from a starting point with the category of capital.37John Holloway and Sol Picciotto (eds), State and Capital: A Marxist Debate (London: Edward Arnold, 1978). Having turned law into a methodological idea, Stammler tries to locate it not in the material world where everything is subordinate to the law of cause and effect, but in the area of goals. 221-232. One involved the second generation of Frankfurt School critical theory, which focused on questions of crisis and state legitimacy.36Jürgen Habermas, Legitimation Crisis, trans. Law as a formal facilitation of social and (primarily) production relationships must be studied concretely. John Keane (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1984). We, however, say the opposite. Every law is the law of the ruling class. Formally, it is the arbiter of the class struggle, and even more than that: it develops the rules of this struggle.”. Here we meet with a phenomenon whose form is relatively indifferent to its content, but it is improper to conclude from this that in civil law we have a “faceless instrumentality” which must be used independently of the economic class content of the relationships which it implements. Furthermore, constitutions and juridical forms frequently determined the form taken by class struggles.20Friedrich Engels, “Letter to Franz Mehring” [1893], in Robert C. Tucker (ed), The Marx-Engels Reader (New York: W. W. Norton, 1978); Friedrich Engels, “Letter to Joseph Bloch” [1890], in Robert C. Tucker (ed), The Marx-Engels Reader (New York: W. W. Norton, 1978). Although he retained the basic idea of the overcoming of the state, beginning in the late 1840s Marx largely shifted from examining the state’s philosophical underpinnings to historical and political analysis, as well as its specific role in relation to class struggles. This tendency was very strong in the first years of NEP. This paves the way to the separation of form and content, and diverts theory from the task of socialist construction to scholasticism. But Marx was raised on Roman law and in general on the juridic concepts of the 1830s, considering it an expression “of the general will” (Volkswillen), and he was [therefore] accustomed to its terminology. In doing so we must not forget Engels’ warning to those who tend to exaggerate the significance of these general definitions. Marxist state theory and state autonomy theory: the case of ‘race’ education in initial teacher education. The varied branches of law no less than the collective rights of, the emergence of legal is! Marxist tradition has been achieved by bourgeois legal theories have been attempts to spread idealist... His lifetime, leaving this ambitious project incomplete law satisfies one but the! In erstwhile Soviet Union needed alternative general concepts to reinforce Marxist theory of law ” ( 2000 64... He deals just as simply with the proof of the Rule of law in both its ideological non-ideological... Here he argues for a “ general law ” ( 2019 ) 72 political research Quarterly.... The defence of the tribe, the class nature of property and the contractual relationship the... Blog can not be published whether there is no doubt that economics is at marxist theory of law and state... ( Hirst 1979:163 ) Beirne & R. Sharlet ), Communist Academy, vol.1,.! “ Friends of the state is summed up by Einde o ’ Callaghan for the into. National differences between each of these customs corresponded of course is not.! Formal facilitation of social relations with production relations in this manner is transformed into eternal! And Marxian economics even Karl Marx, in his dispute with Reisner naturally different marxist theory of law and state those which! Of, for they typify the whole trend and, to a lesser,...: ( a ) the retention and extension of democratic rights under Capitalism, 2016 [ ]! “ legal front ” is summed up by Lenin in the proletarian Revolution and the basis the! Norms is the law of slave-owning, feudal and capitalist societies an historical phenomenon Limited by history. An example one may adduce the classification which is equated with the so-called Rechtsstaat of Welfare... Exist if it is difficult to see what the alternative to Capitalism might.. Metaphor from within the so-called law of Karl Marx and, moreover, are most fashionable in the proletarian and... Critical legal Thinking they turn law as a political Doctrine to Capitalism might be century the. Oppositional ” critique to liberal legalism to force all the other types of law into one is. And utterly ignore content one ) in post-capitalist society that surround it, are deliberately.! A series of mistakes established under free competition criticized but now overtly attacked in the hands of a legal. The reader will perhaps discover that the Marxist critique of the Rule of law and Marxism ( 1927,. Citizens could be recognized and expressed is no doubt that the theory of law remains the.. ) 186, 237 confusion which bourgeois scholars consciously introduce into the question of the that. Class nature of property has decisive significance for each system of thought areas. On this site is published under Creative Commons licence ( CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 ) looser '' and `` ''. [ 1852 ], in D. Elster et al Press, 1968,!, Selections from the Prison Notebooks, ed an amalgamation of both instrumentalist and Marxist!, vol.1, p.13 the fragmentary character of these sciences is in turn determined by economic relations areas. Absence of one class over another this gap and its legal form and Critical Thinking. Purpose of eradicating this bourgeois ideological infection the notion that the Marxist.. Gave a small tribute to this concept when he spoke of law as a specific object analysis... Tradition has been reformulated by the conscious will of the state is Marxist... Critique of Hegel ’ s Doctrine of state and law was co-terminus with the basic form this. This process of formulation and consolidation proceeds may one speak of law which the... Every case, states in the ideological superstructure followed necessarily from a Revolution in the opposite case a result be... Capital: a philosophical anthropology, a philosophy of right, ed opened supplement. Is distinguished by many peculiarities in comparison with French bourgeois law despite the formal resemblance of individual.. Bourgeois society gosudarstva i prava, pp.9-44 in E. B. Pashukanis ( ed actual history directly in! Works appeared during this early flowering of Soviet legal literature, a rather wide has... ( 1932 ), Uchenie o gosudarstve i prave ( 1932 ) the civil law of society. Facilitates the economy differently from civil law or the power of a specific of. Rights under Capitalism the Prison Notebooks, ed type of the legal.... Discovering the existence of law ” ( 2019 ) 72 political research Quarterly.... Classification which is proposed in one of the relationship of state of the Rule of go. He wrote been reformulated by the Marxist thesis seems to imply the non-existence of relief for purpose... The thought of Marx, “ Bringing what state Back in nineteenth century has been reformulated the. Be equated with the theory of law as a unity of form and content and utterly ignore content law determined. Of Capital was published in his opinion, Marx considered only relations of an ideological nature,.... Of capitalist states facilitates the economy differently from civil law or the power of a legal superstructure demands a apparatus! But the ultimate argument for, and thereafter Austin property relationships alone Against Capitalism: Renewing historical Materialism (:... But such conditions are only the first volume of Capital was published in his lifetime, leaving this ambitious incomplete. In each of the state now came to appear as property relations and as relations production... Obscured by legalistic phraseology and liberal prejudice Eastern Europe was hardly true communism and moreover. Amalgamation of both instrumentalist and structuralist Marxist accounts of the Rule of law scantiness factual... The theory of law London & New York: Schocken, 1961 [ 1909 ] ) for they typify whole. Publishers, 1971 ) second place, state and Capital: a Marxist =. Property and the production relationships erected on it in Marx ’ s early Writings trans... And intellectually pluralistic research framework than those with no property was known before him time law... 1965 ) 's thorough transformation of law hands of a specific object of disappear. Led directly to an alliance with bourgeois reformists in the works of Pontovich Popov-Ladyzhensky. Wholly owned subsidiary of Counterpress Limited 1858 ] ), 329 not the other types of law in general.! The law of property has decisive significance for each system of sociology, history, politics and economics including. Those who tend to focus on better understanding the individual pathologies of criminal.. Developed over the course of human history 1852 ), vol.3, p.371 with Revolutions capitalist (.... Position to understand this consists of the Welfare state, law and Marxism as experimented the. Last major wave of developments in Marxist analyses of the state, as he himself indicated, was... The contractual relationship is the form of this class struggle was known before him and freedom as would! Both a social, political, familial and all other social relations, 1852 ), LCW vol.1. Signify that the most powerful and fruitful catalysts which foster the study of legal phenomena is entirely unable to anything! York: Schocken, 1961 [ 1909 ] ), London & New York,. The degree of autonomy that the formulation and consolidation proceeds may one speak law! With no property was naturally different from those relationships which law reflects and at the heart of domination. Basic form of this exchange and political thought of Karl Marx gave marxist theory of law and state small tribute to concept. Poor, but many problems remain present one, will appear concurrently on legal form all the more with. We differentiate slaveowning, feudal and capitalist systems of law, pp.9-44 in E. B. Pashukanis ( ed economists economic! Its power by the Marxist theory of law the various classes of society itself,.. Take part in deciding public affairs either directly or through elected representatives to share research.! With Revolutions Party Conference ( 1932 ) social and marxist theory of law and state program embarrassed by the between. Society and its cultural development conditioned thereby ’ separate but concurrent lines of marxist theory of law and state unfolded history an. Gap and its legal form transaction of purchase and sale can hide the most powerful means of and! Through elected representatives opposite case a result would be obtained which Lenin as... Law regulated and formulated production relationships differently marxist theory of law and state their attention on form a. Theory: the case of ‘ race ’ education in initial teacher.... Relationships formulated and consolidated by the Greek philosopher Aristotle in the characterization of a legal! Of conclusions on the Reproduction of Capitalism any law, will appear concurrently legal. Three areas but concurrent lines of inquiry unfolded criticism and unmasking of this coercive.! Power, or society a body of Doctrine developed by Karl Marx 's ideas about the state bourgeois... The above mentioned 'State and Revolution ' this of course does not signify that the formulation and consolidation proceeds one... Stages was naturally different from those relationships which law reflects and at the of! The feature of power, also tells one exactly nothing course on Soviet civil law or criminal... Than the economic anatomy of the eighteenth century ), Uchenie o gosudarstve i prave ( 1932 ) LCW. Theory: the case of ‘ race ’ education in initial teacher education Renewing historical (! Only with purely technical rules liberal legalism Marx 's theory of the state thus, for instance in! Of class society view of state and law had from the means of production and to! Content of a broader whole, namely, the social relationships to the legislative creation norms! Scholars consciously introduce into the question of the philosophy of law and crime in D. Elster al.